Chloe Temple and her adopted sister Winter Bell have been locked down together. As they do laundry together, they commiserate about how much they miss dick. Chloe points out that they have a stepbrother, Jay Romero. The girls laugh about it, but now that Chloe has the idea in her head she decides to take some action. She asks Jay how he’s handling the lockdown. Winter sees what Chloe is up to. She wants some of the action, so she plops down beside Jay and strongly suggests that he should massage her back as she takes off her shirt. Jay is confused, but he gives Winter what she wants. Chloe isn’t about to let Winter steal her thunder, though, so the next thing Jay knows Chloe is flashing him her tits and pointing out that hers are better. The girls are in a full-on competition now as they each show Jay their ass and tell him to choose which one is better. They escalate further with Winter mocking Chloe’s bush and Chloe pointing out that her pussy is way hotter than Winter’s bare twat. Jay would just like both girls to cut it out, but neither of them care what he thinks. They’re much more interested in determining who’s best at getting into Jay’s pants. When Chloe realizes that Jay has a hardon, she goes for it without caring what Jay or Winter thinks. Winter is right there with Chloe, and the next thing Jay knows his sisters have both whipped out his dick to start sucking and stroking together. The girls’ competition intensifies until they abandon their double BJ to each try fucking Jay so he can tell them which one is the best at banging. Chloe gets the first ride on Jay’s fuck stick. When she hops off, Winter hops on to take her brother for a spin. The sight of Winter fucking Jay is so hot that Chloe begins to masturbate. That prompts Jay to urge both girls into a double pussy stack with Winter on top of Chloe so he can give it to both of them from behind. The girls get on their backs next, laying side by side with their legs spread wide as Jay enjoys both of their dripping charms. When he cums, it is to give Chloe a creampie that Winter happily laps up and snowballs with her sis.